Skip to main content

Another crushing loss for the Cowboys: Is this the end of Mike McCarthy’s run with Dallas?

Posted on October 28, 2024 - 9:43 am by

With Dallas unable to compete against strong teams, the franchise faces hard questions about leadership and direction

TheDallas Cowboys’ season, once brimming with optimism, seems to be teetering on the edge of collapse following yet another disheartening defeat. Sunday night’s matchup against the San Francisco 49ers was supposed to be an opportunity for redemption, a chance to rebound after their recent blowout loss to the Detroit Lions. But instead, the Cowboys found themselves in familiar territory-outmatched and outclassed by a team they hoped to measure up to.

For fans, there was still some room for hope. Dallas may be 3-4, a record that doesn’t spell complete disaster in the NFL, especially when the playoff race is still wide open. But what’s becoming more apparent is that the Cowboys have yet to prove they can rise to the challenge against top-tier teams, an issue that has plagued them all season and raised serious questions about leadership at the helm.



Once again, Dallas entered this game off a bye week, seemingly recharged and prepared to make a statement. Yet, the 49ers quickly took control, exploiting weaknesses on both sides of the ball. By the third quarter, San Francisco led by 17 points, having out-gained Dallas 381-167 in total yardage-a stark indication of the Cowboys’ inability to keep pace with stronger opponents.

The fourth quarter offered a glimpse of hope, with Dallas managing to score two touchdowns. But even then, the effort felt hollow, as San Francisco’s defense primarily played shell coverage, keeping the Cowboys’ offense in check. When Dak Prescott finally had a shot to engineer a game-winning drive, it ended abruptly in a four-and-out, not gaining a single yard.

It’s a scene that’s becoming all too familiar this season. Back in Week 2, the Cowboys were steamrolled by the New Orleans Saints, 44-19. Just a week later, they faced the Baltimore Ravens, who were up 28-6 before allowing Dallas a comeback that fell short, mirroring Sunday’s game. Though the Cowboys outscored the Ravens 19-0 in the final quarter, Baltimore held on for the win-just as the 49ers did.



Facing tougher opponents ahead, McCarthy’s Cowboys must prove their worth

What’s troubling is that the Cowboys’ wins this season have come against teams struggling to find their own rhythm. Victories over the Cleveland Browns, New York Giants, and Pittsburgh Steelers provided brief respite but did little to quell doubts about the team’s long-term prospects. These wins, though necessary, haven’t showcased the kind of resilience or firepower needed to succeed in the postseason.

Looking ahead, the Cowboys’ schedule doesn’t offer much comfort. Their next four opponents-the Atlanta Falcons, Philadelphia Eagles, Houston Texans, and Washington Commanders-boast a combined record of 22-9. These matchups will be make-or-break for Dallas, and anything short of a complete turnaround may spell the end of head coach Mike McCarthy’s tenure.

For McCarthy, the pressure is mounting. While he’s had moments of success with the Cowboys, his inability to secure wins against premier teams casts a shadow over his future in Dallas. If the Cowboys continue their current trajectory, ownership may decide that a new approach is needed to guide the franchise forward.



So, is this truly the end of McCarthy’s run with Dallas? While no official word has been made, the writing is on the wall. As the Cowboys face a daunting stretch, the focus will be on whether McCarthy can inspire a turnaround-or if his time at the helm is already drawing to a close.